Where NMR marks are won and lost
The hard part of an NMR question is rarely reading a single peak — it is pulling every peak, its splitting and the molecular formula together into one structure, and then writing that reasoning down. Examiner reports find that, in spectroscopy questions, only the strongest answers integrate all the spectral and formula data into a structure, and that weaker answers frequently reach the right structure without enough explanation to access the top marks. The lesson is to state the deduction, not just the label — write “triplet, so two hydrogens on the neighbouring carbon” rather than just “triplet”.
These questions also follow a fixed shape. They usually give you the molecular or empirical formula, often an infrared or 13C clue alongside the 1H peaks — and they want the same three things read off each peak. Learn to work one peak at a time and the whole question becomes a routine.
The method: one peak at a time
Every proton (1H) NMR peak carries three separate pieces of information. Take them in this order and squeeze all three out of each peak before moving on:
- Integration → how many H. The relative peak area (the integration trace, or the numbers given) tells you how many hydrogens are in that environment.
- Splitting → how many H on the neighbour. Number of lines minus one, by the n+1 rule. A triplet means 2 neighbouring H, a quartet means 3.
- Shift → the environment. Read δ against Table B of the Data Booklet — is this H near an O, a halogen, a C=O, or just an alkyl chain?
Write each peak up as a single fragment, then join the fragments so the hydrogen count matches the molecular formula.
The shift table is given to you in the exam — you are not tested on recalling the numbers, only on using them. That is why the right way to revise is with the table open, which is exactly how the analyser further down works.
Why the reasoning matters, not just the answer
A common misconception is that getting the structure right guarantees the marks. It doesn’t. The longer “deduce the structure” questions are often marked by levels of response — the band you land in depends on how completely you justify the structure, not only on whether it is correct. Examiner reports describe the top level as reserved for answers that integrate all the data; a right structure with thin explanation is capped below it.
So the safest way to reach the top band is to make your reasoning visible for every peak — write the deduction as a chain, not as a private thought process with only the final answer shown.
A worked example, start to finish
This is a real AQA past-paper question — a six-mark “deduce the structure” task that combines three techniques. Work it yourself first, then read the stage-by-stage analysis, a top-band answer, and how the levels-of-response marks are awarded.
This question is about compound X with the empirical formula C2H4O. Figure 2 shows the infrared spectrum of X. Figure 3 shows the 13C NMR spectrum of X. The 1H NMR spectrum of X shows four peaks with different chemical shift values. Table 3 gives data for these peaks.
Figure 2
Figure 3
Table 3
| Chemical shift δ / ppm | 3.9 | 3.7 | 2.1 | 1.2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Splitting pattern | quartet | singlet | singlet | doublet |
| Integration value | 1 | 1 | 3 | 3 |
Show how information from Figure 2, Figure 3 and Table 3 can be used to deduce the structure of compound X.
Source: AQA A-level Chemistry, Paper 2 (7405/2), June 2022, Question 6.
Notice the command: “show how… can be used to deduce”. That phrasing signals a levels-of-response question — the marks are for the chain of reasoning across all three techniques, not just the final structure. The mark scheme groups the work into three stages: infrared, then 1H NMR, then 13C NMR.
Stage 1 — infrared: the functional groups
Two absorptions, two clues:
- Broad absorption at 3400 cm−1 → an O–H of an alcohol.
- Strong peak at 1720 cm−1 → a C=O.
So X contains both a hydroxyl group and a carbonyl.
Stage 2 — 1H NMR: the hydrogens and the formula
- δ 2.1, singlet, 3 H → a CH3 with no H on the neighbour; the shift (2.1–2.6) puts it next to C=O → CH3–CO–.
- δ 1.2, doublet, 3 H → a CH3 next to a single H (a CH) → CH3–CH–.
- δ 3.9, quartet, 1 H → one H on a carbon bonded to O; quartet, so next to a CH3 → –CH–O.
- δ 3.7, singlet, 1 H → the non-coupling O–H proton, matching the IR alcohol.
- Integration totals 1 + 1 + 3 + 3 = 8 H. The empirical formula C2H4O has 4 H, so the molecular formula is twice it: C4H8O2.
Stage 3 — 13C NMR: confirm the carbons
Four peaks means four carbon environments — consistent with C4H8O2:
- δ 210 → C=O of an aldehyde or ketone (here a ketone).
- δ 75 → a carbon singly bonded to O (the C–OH).
- δ 25 and 20 → two different alkyl carbons (the two CH3 groups).
Putting it together
The three techniques have handed you four fragments and a formula. Now connect them one bond at a time:
- List the pieces from the 1H NMR: CH3–CO– (from δ 2.1), CH3–CH– (from δ 1.2), –CH–O (from δ 3.9) and –O–H (from δ 3.7).
- The doublet CH3 and the quartet CH are neighbours, so join them: CH3–CH–. That CH is the one on a C–O, and it carries the O–H — so it is a CH3–CH(OH)– unit (confirmed by the δ 75 C–OH in the 13C).
- That CH still has one bond spare. The only fragment left is the methyl ketone, so attach it there: CH3–CO–CH(OH)–CH3.
- Check against everything: C4H8O2 (8 H, 4 C), four carbon environments in the 13C, and both the C=O and O–H the IR demanded. All accounted for.
So compound X is CH3COCH(OH)CH3 — 3-hydroxybutan-2-one.
How to present it — a top-band answer
Because this is levels-marked, the examiner is looking for a coherent chain that moves through all three stages. This is what a Level 3 answer reads like:
🎯 Model answer — deducing the structure of X
Infrared — the broad peak at 3400 cm−1 shows an O–H (alcohol); the peak at 1720 cm−1 shows a C=O.
1H NMR — take each peak in turn and draw the fragment it gives:
δ 2.1 (singlet, 3 H) → a CH3 with no neighbouring H, so next to the C=O:
δ 1.2 (doublet, 3 H) → a CH3 next to a single H (a CH):
δ 3.9 (quartet, 1 H) → that CH — one H on a carbon bonded to O:
δ 3.7 (singlet, 1 H) → the hydroxyl O–H:
The integrations total 1 + 1 + 3 + 3 = 8 H, so the molecular formula is C4H8O2.
13C NMR — four peaks = four carbon environments: δ 210 (C=O), δ 75 (C–OH), and δ 25 and 20 (the two CH3 carbons).
Structure — the fragments join into 3-hydroxybutan-2-one, CH3COCH(OH)CH3:
How the marks are awarded
The biggest misconception is that the right structure earns full marks automatically. It doesn’t. This question is marked by levels of response, so the band depends on how completely and coherently you cover the three stages:
- Level 3 (5–6): all three stages covered, generally correct, with a logical progression from the IR clue through the two NMR spectra to the structure.
- Level 2 (3–4): all three stages touched but incomplete or with slips, or two stages done fully.
- Level 1 (1–2): isolated correct statements, not tied into a line of reasoning.
That is why a correct structure with thin working is capped low — the marks live in the chain of reasoning, so write every stage down.
The mistakes that cost the marks
- Reading splitting the wrong way: lines = neighbours + 1, so a triplet means 2 H next door, not 3.
- Counting environments wrong — equivalent H share one peak, so symmetry lowers the count.
- Letting an –OH or –NH split its neighbour — it usually doesn’t couple, and often shows as a broad singlet.
- Ignoring the molecular formula — your integration H-total must add up to it.
- Treating the IR and NMR clues in isolation, or not accounting for every signal — examiner reports flag both as reasons answers stall below the top level.
Practise until it’s automatic — the NMR analyser
Reading about the method is not the same as owning it. This is the same interactive I built for my A-Level NMR revision notes, dropped in here so you can drill it now. Read a spectrum works exactly like the exam: take each peak in turn, fix its integration, splitting and Data-Booklet environment, collect the exam-answer lines, then sketch the structure before revealing it. Predict a spectrum runs the drill in reverse. The 13C drill does the lighter carbon version — count the environments, place the peaks.
Interactive — the NMR analyser
Data Booklet shift tables (open while you work)
First revise the topic, then drill it
If the analyser is exposing gaps — you’re unsure what a shift means, or how splitting arises — go back to the full notes before you keep drilling. My A-Level revision page covers chemical shift and Table B, integration, the n+1 splitting rule, the 13C version and more worked spectra, all with the interactive built in.
AQA A-Level NMR spectroscopy — full revision notes · chemical shift, integration, splitting, 13C, and the shift tables. Free, no sign-up, works on your phone.
Common questions
How do you work out a structure from an NMR spectrum?
One peak at a time. Integration gives the number of hydrogens in that environment, splitting gives the number of neighbours (lines − 1), and the chemical shift — read from Table B of the Data Booklet — gives the environment. Write each peak as a fragment, then join the fragments to fit the molecular formula.
How many marks are NMR questions worth?
It varies with the question — a short “deduce and explain” may credit each reasoned step, while a longer structure-deduction is often marked by levels of response, where the quality of your explanation sets the band. In both cases the reasoning is what’s marked, not just the final structure, so always show it.
Do I have to memorise the chemical shift values?
No — AQA gives you Table B (proton) and Table C (carbon-13) in the Data Booklet. You’re tested on using them, not recalling them, so revise with the table open.
What’s the difference between 13C and 1H NMR questions?
Carbon-13 is lighter: count the carbon environments (equivalent carbons share a peak) and place each in a Table C region. Proton NMR carries more per peak — integration and splitting — so it’s where the full method earns the most.